💀 Marketing Autopsy: $100 Million Logo Disaster + Corporate Groupthink Warning

Welcome Back to TWISM’s Autopsy Series!

In this series, we examine the biggest actual marketing deaths worldwide. While others made expensive mistakes, 70K+ TWISM readers are learning from their failures for free.

Keep in mind that these bi-weekly Sunday autopsies could save your career.

Sponsored -💰 Same VCs Who Backed Uber Just Made This $1B+ Company Available to You.

Keep This Stock Ticker on Your Watchlist

They’re a private company, but Pacaso just reserved the Nasdaq ticker “$PCSO.”

No surprise the same firms that backed Uber, eBay, and Venmo already invested in Pacaso. What is unique is Pacaso is giving the same opportunity to everyday investors. And 10,000+ people have already joined them.

Created a former Zillow exec who sold his first venture for $120M, Pacaso brings co-ownership to the $1.3T vacation home industry.

They’ve generated $1B+ worth of luxury home transactions across 2,000+ owners. That’s good for more than $110M in gross profit since inception, including 41% YoY growth last year alone.

And you can join them today for just $2.90/share. But don’t wait too long. Invest in Pacaso before the opportunity ends September 18.

Invest While You Still Can

_{Paid advertisement for Pacaso’s Regulation A offering. Read the offering circular at invest.pacaso.com. Reserving a ticker symbol is not a guarantee that the company will go public. Listing on the NASDAQ is subject to approvals.}

🔬 The Main Autopsy: Cracker Barrel's Catastrophic Logo Lobotomy

Patient Details

Brand: Cracker Barrel Old Country Store.
Campaign: "All The More" Logo Rebrand.
Budget: $94-100 million lost in market value.
Cause of Death: Executive hubris combined with groupthink paralysis.
Time of Death: August 19, 2025.

What They Intended

Cracker Barrel aimed to shed its "outdated" image through a $700 million modernization plan, targeting younger consumers with a sleeker, text-only logo that removed the iconic "Old Timer" character. CEO Julie Felss Masino stated the goal was to "regain relevance" and attract new clientele.

What Actually Happened

• Stock plummeted 12-15% immediately after the announcement, erasing $94-100 million in market value.

• Conservative backlash erupted across social media, with President Trump and Donald Trump Jr. criticizing the change.

• Customers accused the brand of "going woke" and abandoning its heritage.

• Complete reversal announced within 8 days of original announcement.

• White House trolled the company with AI-generated videos mocking the rebrand.

The Numbers

• Stock dropped from $59.02 to $50.76 in one day (August 21).

• Market capitalization loss: $94-100 million.

• RepTrak reputation score fell more than 10 points, dropping from "strong" to "average".

• Stock recovery of 8% after the reversal announcement.

• $700 million total transformation budget spanning 3 years.

• Only 4 out of 660 locations had been renovated before reversal.

Timeline of Destruction

• May 2024: Company announces $700 million transformation plan.

• August 19, 2025: New logo unveiled on Good Morning America with "All The More" campaign.

• August 21, 2025: Stock crashes 12-15%, losing nearly $100 million in value.

• August 25, 2025: Trump criticizes rebrand on Truth Social, stock rises 6%.

• August 26, 2025: Complete logo reversal announced, stock jumps another 8%.

• September 2025: Restaurant redesign plans also suspended.

💰 TWISM Affiliate Program - Turn Your Network Into Income

Earn up to $1 for every subscriber you refer to the newsletter 80,000+ marketers trust!

Why our affiliate program rocks:

• $1 per subscriber (industry-leading rates)

• 20% bonus on referred affiliates

• Ready-made promotional materials provided

• $10 minimum payout with monthly payments

• 30-day cookie tracking captures every conversion

Perfect for: Marketing professionals, content creators, social media managers, and anyone with an audience that values quality marketing insights.

Your audience already follows you for marketing advice - now get paid when you share the resource they actually need.

✨ Want to advertise in TWISM?
Reach 70K+ social media pros who read TWISM

Book TWISM Ad »

✨ Monetize Your Social Media Audience
Earn 30% Recurring Revenue with the Post Planner Affiliate Program

Become an Affiliate »

🧬 Failure DNA Analysis

The Root Cause: Echo Chamber Executive Syndrome

Cognitive Bias #1: Groupthink
Cracker Barrel's leadership fell victim to classic groupthink behavior, where the desire for harmony overrode critical thinking. The $700 million transformation plan was developed through internal research that clearly missed the emotional connection customers had with the brand's heritage.

Cognitive Bias #2: Sunk Cost Fallacy
Despite clear warning signs during the rollout, executives continued pushing forward because of the massive investment already made. The company had already committed to the $700 million transformation, making it psychologically difficult to change course.

Warning Signs They Ignored:

1. Attempts to modernize started to fail, with 2024 sales remaining stagnant.

2. Stock had already dropped 40% in 2024 before the logo change

3. Core demographic of traditionalists (65+) had shown resistance to previous changes.

4. Investor warnings about the modernization plan from major shareholders like Sardar Biglari.

Why Smart People Made This Dumb Decision:
Research shows that diverse teams are 33% more likely to outperform homogeneous ones, but Cracker Barrel's leadership appears to have suffered from confirmation bias. CEO Julie Masino's background at Taco Bell and other modern brands may have created an echo chamber where "modernization equals success" went unchallenged.

🎭 Myth Busted: "Playing It Safe Protects Brand Value"

The Myth: Old-fashioned brands need sleek, minimalist logos to attract younger consumers and stay relevant.

The Reality: Brand heritage can be a competitive advantage, not a liability.

• Cracker Barrel's "everyone has a Cracker Barrel origin story" emotional connection was their biggest asset.

• The company's nostalgic appeal worked across age groups, not just seniors.

• Stock recovery happened immediately after reverting to the original logo, proving heritage value.

• Only 4 renovated locations out of 660 total showed early results that weren't compelling enough to justify full rollout.

Why This Myth Persists:
The "tech company aesthetic" has become the default for modernization efforts, with executives unconsciously pattern-matching to Silicon Valley success stories. This creates a false equivalence between visual simplicity and business growth.

What to Do Instead:
Evolve within your brand DNA rather than abandoning it entirely. Update execution while preserving core visual and emotional equity.

🛡️ Failure Prevention Toolkit: The "Heritage Brand Evaluation Checklist"

Before launching any major rebrand:

✓ Legacy Asset Audit

• Document all brand elements that create an emotional connection.

• Survey customers about specific visual and experiential touchpoints they value.

• Quantify the financial value of heritage elements through market research.

✓ Decision-Making Safeguards

• Assign a dedicated "devil's advocate" team member for major initiatives.

• Require external customer validation before internal approval.

• Set "circuit breakers" - predetermined metrics that trigger strategy review.

✓ Stakeholder Stress Testing

• Test concepts with vocal critics and brand loyalists, not just target demographics.

• Include political/cultural sensitivity review for heritage brands.

• Map potential negative scenarios and response plans.

✓ Implementation Risk Management

• Pilot test in limited markets before full rollout.

• Build in reversal mechanisms and timeline flexibility.

• Prepare crisis communication strategies for multiple scenarios.

Red Flags to Watch For:

• The leadership team lacks diverse perspectives or external input.

• Major investments were made without customer validation.

• Internal excitement not matched by external research data.

• Dismissing negative feedback as "resistance to change".

Screenshots save careers. Which failure lesson are you bookmarking?

Forward this to someone who needs to see it.

P.S. - Have a social media disaster story to share anonymously? Reply with "AUTOPSY" and I'll send you our submission guidelines.

That’s all for today. Thanks for reading. Now…

Go BIG or go home!

~ Josh from “This Week in Social Media”

Brought to you by Post Planner

You are receiving this newsletter because you previously opted in to Post Planner’s emails.

You can unsubscribe in one click below… but PLEASE DON’T! 😂

Disclaimer: Some links may be affiliate links that pay us commissions.

Was this newsletter forwarded to you? 

Subscribe to “This Week in Social Media” here »